The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel has ruled there were six on-field errors in the last round of games — the joint-highest total it has recorded in a single weekend.
The last time six mistakes were logged in one weekend was early in the 2023-24 season. The panel, five members who assess the contentious incidents from every round and vote on whether the referee and the VAR got each decision right, judged two of the six to be VAR errors as well as on-field mistakes.
The weekend’s controversies began on Friday, when Coventry should have had a penalty after Everton’s James Tarkowski pulled Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair inside the box. No spot-kick was given, and the panel voted 5-0 that both the on-field decision and the VAR were incorrect. “Tarkowski had a hold of Yirenkyi’s hair and the panel unanimously felt that VAR should have intervened,” the panel said.
Arsenal were also denied a penalty at Hull, after Kai Havertz was brought down in the box by Nobel Mendy. VAR Michael Oliver sent referee Farai Hallam to the pitchside monitor, but no penalty was awarded because Havertz was judged to be offside. The panel again voted 5-0 that both decisions were wrong, ruling that Mendy’s holding was clear and impactful — and happened before any potential offside offence. Arsenal still won the game 1-0.
The other four errors were judged to be on-field mistakes only, with the VAR judged right not to intervene. Everton striker Thierno Barry put his side ahead against Coventry in the 61st minute, but the goal was checked for a possible handball. Three of the five panellists felt the on-field decision to allow the goal was wrong, with the panel noting that, on the balance of probability, the ball did accidentally strike Barry’s hand — but all five agreed VAR was right not to intervene because the available footage did not provide conclusive evidence.
Crystal Palace were awarded a penalty against Liverpool three minutes into stoppage time, for Milos Kerkez’s challenge on Dario Osorio. The panel was unanimous that the penalty was incorrect, with the contact inevitable as both players jumped, but again agreed VAR was right to stay out of it because the error was not clear and obvious. Liverpool won the game 3-1.
Ipswich were awarded a penalty in the 72nd minute against Bournemouth, for Lewis Cook’s challenge on Abdoul Ouattara. The panel voted 4-1 that the award was wrong, ruling that Ouattara had stepped across Cook, who had not made a challenge — but that VAR was right not to intervene. Bournemouth’s Marcus Tavernier should also have been sent off for a second yellow card for a clear, deliberate attempt to delay the restart late in his side’s 2-1 win at Ipswich, although second yellow cards cannot be reviewed by VAR.
The six errors do not include correct VAR interventions, such as the red card shown to Brentford’s Igor Thiago. The panel also backed four other disputed calls from the weekend, including Leeds defender Jayden Bogle escaping a red card for his challenge on Tottenham’s Mathys Tel, and a penalty for Sunderland after Levi Colwill tripped Brian Bobbey. The panel’s findings matter beyond embarrassment: they feed into a merit table that accounts for half of referees’ pay in bonus payments.
Six on-field mistakes in one weekend — plus the Thiago red card — is clearly a high number, and the findings will add to the scrutiny on officiating when the Premier League resumes this weekend.




